Magic Mind: claims workflow demo

Fictional cases. Public carrier rules. No live submissions.

Demo clockThu 24 Sep 2026Rules read at the source that day
Case C-1042, our internal ID: not a claim number

Broken bottles, photos in two messages

Dana R., order 48213, subscription order: 30 bottles of Magic Mind Original, $74.25 paid. UPS Ground 1Z8F429A0318462279, shipped Thu 17 Sep, delivered Tue 22 Sep at 2:10 pm.

To validate
As of Thu 24 Sep 2026. Replay what happens after filing, one simulated event at a time.

Next action

Check the 3 photos a model read, then send the claim form to Shopify Support

Owner

Claims owner

Due

Today
Complete form within 2 business days of the first report (set by us); UPS must receive notice by 21 Nov, through Shopify Support

Blocked by

  • 3 photos read by a model, not yet checked by a person

Deadlines

Computed from the carrier's own event dates, never from the day the ticket was opened.

Notice to UPS60 days after delivery21 Nov58 days left
21 Nov58 days left
Claim filed with UPS9 months after delivery22 Jun 2027271 days left
How it got here
  1. 17 SepShipped
  2. 22 SepDelivered 2:10 pm; Message 1, 2 photos
  3. 23 SepMessage 2, 1 photo
  4. 24 SepToday, on the demo clock

Filing route

Who files, where, and where the money lands

Through Shopify Support

Service
UPS, UPS Ground
Label bought through
Shopify Shipping
Shipping account holder
Not in the label recordto confirm
Coverage
UPS limit of $100, no declared value on the label; no Package Shield; no Shipsurance on this label record
Entitled to claim
The shipper or someone on its behalf; here the store, through Shopify Support
Indemnity paid to
Not stated on Shopify's pageto confirm
Where to file
Claim form on the Shopify order page, sent to Shopify Support
Case file prepared: fields and documents ready for a person to file at ups.com or usps.com.
Transmitted to an operator or partner: sent to Shopify Support, Shipsurance or Redo; the destination and what remains stay visible.
Integrated filing: not active. Only after access is verified; nothing is submitted from this page.

Amounts

Missing stays missing

Documented value of the goods affected
$9.90

4 bottles × $2.475 paid per bottle on this order ($74.25 for 30); count stated by the customer

Claimed
$9.90

The documented value, under the $100 limit.

Approved
No decision yet

Set by the carrier, never by this page

Received
Nothing yet

Counted only when the money or credit is seen

Evidence

What the file holds, who holds it, and what is still asked for

Tracking number and date of shipmentLabel recordOn file. 1Z8F429A0318462279, shipped Thu 17 Sep
What happened, in the customer's wordsCustomer, message 1In hand. From the customer's message Model reading; a person checks it.
How many bottles are brokenCustomer, message 2In hand. 4 broken, as the customer states Model reading; a person checks it.
Photo: broken bottles and how they were packedCustomer, message 1In hand. IMG_4102.jpg Model reading; a person checks it.
Photo: label with the tracking numberCustomer, message 2In hand. IMG_4110.jpg, tracking number matches the shipment Model reading; a person checks it.
Photo: outside of the boxCustomer, message 1In hand. IMG_4103.jpg Model reading; a person checks it.
Box dimensionsPackaging specOn file. 30-bottle carton, 11 x 9 x 5 in
Merchandise descriptionOrder recordOn file. Written from order 48213: "4 Magic Mind Original mental performance shots, 2 oz glass bottles, from a 30-bottle carton"
Invoice: price paid for this shipmentOrder recordOn file. Order 48213: 30 bottles of Magic Mind Original, $74.25 paid
Proof the shipping charge was paidLabel recordOn file. 1Z8F429A0318462279, shipped Thu 17 Sep
Box, packaging and every bottle kept for inspectionCustomerAsked to keep. Asked in every reply until the claim is closed

What came in

Photos are described, not shown: the cases are fictional

Italic lines were proposed by a model (Claude Opus 5.5, claude-opus-5-5) reading each message when this demo was built, on Thu 24 Sep 2026. They can stay uncertain. They never decide the cause, the date of the damage, the eligibility or the amount; the code does, from the records.

Message 1, email, ticket #5812, Tue 22 Sep at 7:05 pm

Hi, my Magic Mind box came today and a few bottles are smashed. Everything inside is sticky. Photos attached. Order 48213.

IMG_4102.jpgThe open box from above: broken glass in the dividers, wet cardboard, intact bottles around.
IMG_4103.jpgThe closed box on a porch: one corner crushed, a dark stain on the side.
Inside of the box: broken glass among the dividers, intact bottles around it. The number of broken bottles cannot be counted from this photo.Proposed by Claude Opus 5.5, 24 Sep, on IMG_4102.jpg
Outside of the box: a crushed corner and a stain on one side.Proposed by Claude Opus 5.5, 24 Sep, on IMG_4103.jpg
Customer reports broken bottles and sticky contents on arrival.Proposed by Claude Opus 5.5, 24 Sep, on the message text
Message 2, email, ticket #5812, Wed 23 Sep at 8:31 am

Forgot the label, here it is. 4 are broken, the other 26 look fine but sticky.

IMG_4110.jpgClose-up of the shipping label on the box.
Shipping label; the tracking number reads 1Z8F429A0318462279.Proposed by Claude Opus 5.5, 24 Sep, on IMG_4110.jpg
Code: the number matches the shipment record, so the label photo counts.
Customer counts 4 broken bottles, and 26 intact but sticky.Proposed by Claude Opus 5.5, 24 Sep, on the message text
Code: 4 bottles at the price paid; bottles called sticky or fine are not claimed unless documented.

Reply to the customer

Written by the code from what is still missing

Hi Dana, thank you, we have your three photos and the count. Please keep the box, the packaging and every bottle, broken or not, until we tell you the claim is closed: the carrier may ask to inspect them. Your replacement is handled separately and doesn't wait for this claim.

After filing

External events are simulated; the code handling them is the code under test

  1. 1Thu 24 Sep
    10:20 am
    Claims owner checks the photos a model read
    Action in the case file
    Validated by a person. Ready to file through Shopify Support.
  2. 2Thu 24 Sep
    10:26 am
    Claim form sent to Shopify Support
    Action in the case file
    The page timed out before any answer (simulated). Nobody knows whether the claim arrived: status set to confirmation to verify.
  3. 3Thu 24 Sep
    10:31 am
    Someone tries to send the claim again
    Action in the case file
    Refused by the code. A submission is already pending or on file: check the channel first.
  4. 4Thu 24 Sep
    10:40 am
    Shopify's automated email found in the inbox
    Simulated email from Shopify
    So the claim did arrive: back to sent for filing. The email carries no reference ticket ID: recorded as an acknowledgment, not as a filing.
  5. 5Fri 25 Sep
    9:12 am
    Shopify Support reference #SS-661842
    Simulated reply from Shopify Support
    Partner ticket recorded. It is Shopify Support's number, not the carrier's: still waiting for the carrier claim number.
  6. 6Tue 29 Sep
    3:03 pm
    UPS claim 9041277361, confirmed through Shopify Support
    Simulated, relayed by Shopify Support
    A carrier reference: the filing is confirmed.
  7. 7Fri 2 Oct
    11:00 am
    The carrier asks for a more detailed merchandise description
    Simulated carrier request
    Review paused until the complement is sent. It attaches to the same claim; no new claim.
  8. 8Fri 2 Oct
    1:30 pm
    Complement sent
    Action in the case file
    Sent, written from the order record: "4 Magic Mind Original mental performance shots, 2 oz glass bottles, from a 30-bottle carton".
    Stage now: filing confirmedUPS: A detailed merchandise description
  9. 9Fri 9 Oct
    12:00 pm
    Partial approval, $7.43
    Simulated carrier decision
    3 of the 4 bottles accepted. Approved is not paid: the case stays open until the money is matched.
    Stage now: decision receivedSet by us: Approved is not paid
  10. 10Wed 14 Oct
    9:00 am
    $7.43 received
    Simulated: payment recorded; where it lands on this route is to confirm
    Matched against the $7.43 approved: reconciled, case closed.
    Stage now: settlement reconciledSet by us: Approved is not paid

Every case, traced

The six situations of a claims desk in one line each: what came in, what the model proposed, the rule the code applied, and what it allowed or refused. The late report appears twice, one record apart; the wrong flavor shows a case leaving the carrier circuit.

SituationReceivedProposed by the modelRule appliedAllowed or refused
Case C-1042Received2 messages, 3 photosProposed by the modelCustomer counts 4 broken bottles, and 26 intact but sticky.Rule appliedOne incident, one caseThree photos and the box dimensionsAllowed or refusedTo validate. Check the 3 photos a model read, then send the claim form to Shopify Support.
Case C-1043Received1 message, 1 photoProposed by the modelShipping label; the tracking number is legible. No bottles and no box damage are visible in this photo.Rule appliedPhotos of the extent of damage helpShock damage needs a damaged containerAllowed or refusedTo complete. Send the reply asking for 3 items, 2 of them needed to file.
Case C-1044Received1 message, no photoProposed by the modelCustomer reports the package has not arrived.Rule appliedLoss: from day 15 to day 60 after mailingWho bought each label, on which accountAllowed or refusedTo complete. Find out who bought the label for 9400111899223107452281.
Case C-1045Received1 message, no photoProposed by the modelCustomer reports nothing at the door and says a neighbor was already asked.Rule appliedInvestigate a delivered package before any claimDelivery to the address counts as deliveryTheft after an unsigned delivery: Package ShieldAllowed or refusedInvestigation. Send the reply, then review where UPS left it.
Case C-1046Received3 messages, on 2 tickets, 3 photos; an open Redo claimProposed by the modelCustomer says UPS told her they would pay.Rule appliedOne incident, one caseOne open claim per issueAllowed or refusedSent for filing. Attach IMG_7710.jpg to RD-CLM-20931 and merge ticket #5843 into #5840.
Case C-1047Received2 messages, 3 photos; a notice logged with UPSProposed by the modelCustomer counts 6 broken bottles.Rule appliedUPS must receive notice within 60 daysThe claim itself is filed within 9 monthsups.com: start a claim within 60 daysAllowed or refusedTo validate. Check the 3 photos a model read, then file the claim against the notice of 3 Sep.
Case C-1048Received1 message, 3 photosProposed by the modelCustomer reports 3 broken bottles in the July delivery.Rule appliedUPS must receive notice within 60 daysThe claim itself is filed within 9 monthsAllowed or refusedPast the carrier deadline. Close carrier recovery; the customer's resolution goes on.
Case C-1049Received1 message, 1 photoProposed by the modelBottles in the photo are labeled MAXX; the order is for Original. The box looks intact.Rule appliedWrong item: order number, description, photoAllowed or refusedNot a carrier claim. Resolve it with the customer and log the packing error.

What each guard prevents

The same functions run twice on the same case: as built, then with one guard removed. The test suite asserts both outcomes; these lines are computed live by that code.

GuardAs builtWith the guard removed
Pieces already received are never asked for againCase C-1042The reply asks for nothing new: "Hi Dana, thank you, we have your three photos and the count. Please keep the box, the packaging and every bottle, broken or not, until we tell you the claim is closed: the carrier may ask to inspect them."The reply asks again for 4 items the customer already sent in two messages.
No photos asked of a customer who never received the boxCase C-1044"You don't need to send anything.""Could you send a photo of the broken bottles inside the box, as they arrived, a photo of the shipping label, close enough to read the tracking number and a photo of the outside of the box? Sorting out your order doesn't wait for the carrier."
UPS: notice at 60 days and the claim at 9 months are two deadlinesCase C-1047Notice given on day 50: under the terms the claim can still be filed until 15 Apr 2027 ("Check the 3 photos a model read, then file the claim against the notice of 3 Sep"); past day 60, the online channel is to confirm with UPS.One 60-day deadline: the case is refused as late (UPS claim closed on 13 Sep).
A lost USPS package is not filed before day 15Case C-1044Same case with its label provider known: "Hold the file; file when the window opens", due Wed 30 Sep.Filed on 24 Sep, day 9 after mailing: "Check the file, then file at usps.com". USPS would not accept it yet.
A lost response is verified, never sent twiceCase C-10421 submission; the second attempt is refused and the case waits in confirmation to verify.2 submissions for one box: a duplicate claim, which UPS refuses while one is open.
An automated email is not a filingCase C-1042Shopify's automated email leaves the case at "sent for filing".The same email marks it "filing confirmed" with no reference from anyone.
Approved is not paidCase C-1042After the partial approval the case stays "decision received" until $7.43 is received and matched.The case closes as "settled" before any money arrives.
Two tickets, one box: one claim; the replacement keeps its ownCase C-10461 case for tickets #5840 and #5843; the replacement 1Z8F429A0318480114: new tracking number, its own case.Keyed by ticket: 2 cases, so two claims for one box. Keyed by order: the replacement's claim is blocked.
"UPS said they'd pay" changes nothingCase C-1046Still "sent for filing": the Redo claim has no carrier number yet.Marked "filing confirmed" on the customer's word.
A label photo counts only if it is this package's labelCase C-1042Same case, label photo of another order: refused (IMG_4110.jpg shows 1Z8F429A0318455092, not this shipment); the reply asks for the right one.Accepted as evidence: "Check the 3 photos a model read, then send the claim form to Shopify Support".
Four broken bottles are claimed, not the packCase C-1042$9.90: 4 bottles at $2.475, the price paid per bottle on this order.$74.25: the whole pack of 30, including bottles nobody showed damaged.

Rules and where they come from

60 rules, each with its class and its source; open a line for the full rule. Public pages read on Thu 24 Sep 2026. A passing test proves a rule is applied as written, not that it fits every account: that is what the conditions to confirm are for.

Public rules (38)

Published by UPS, USPS, Shopify and Redo. Each was read at its source; the extracts are kept with the code.

UPSUPS must receive notice within 60 daysUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.3

For domestic shipments, UPS must receive notice of a claim within 60 days after delivery or, if the package was not delivered, within 60 days after the scheduled delivery date. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.3; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSThe claim itself is filed within 9 monthsUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.3

The claim must be filed within nine months after delivery or, if the package was not delivered, within nine months after the scheduled delivery date. Without notice and filing in time, the claim is deemed waived. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.3; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSA notice needs date, tracking number, nature of damageUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.1

A notice of claim gives the date of shipment, the tracking number and the nature of the loss or damage, online at ups.com or by phone at 1-800-PICK-UPS. Asking for proof of delivery or an inspection is not a notice. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.1; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSA claim states an amount and comes with the invoiceUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.1

The written claim states a specified or determinable amount and comes with the original invoice or, if no invoice was issued, other proof of the price paid by the consignee, the actual cost or the replacement cost. UPS pays no claim voluntarily unless it was noticed and filed by or on behalf of the shipper. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.1; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSProof that shipping charges were paidUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.4

Each claim is supported by evidence that the shipping and any declared value charges were paid, and by the invoice or a certification of prices or costs with discounts. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.4; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSOriginal packaging kept for inspectionUPS Terms 2026, Sections 55.4 and 56.3

For a damage claim, the original packaging must be made available to UPS for inspection; UPS may refuse to pay if it is not. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Sections 55.4 and 56.3; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSThree photos and the box dimensionsUPS, File a Claim, FAQ, photo documentation

When UPS asks for photo documentation: the damaged item and how it was packed inside the box, a close-up of the label with the tracking number, and the outside of the package; plus the box dimensions. Source: UPS, File a Claim, FAQ, photo documentation; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSA detailed merchandise descriptionUPS, File a Claim, FAQ, merchandise description and claim statuses

The merchandise description uses descriptors such as brand, size, container type, model and quantity; without enough detail UPS cannot complete the investigation until it is supplied. Source: UPS, File a Claim, FAQ, merchandise description and claim statuses; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSUPS may ask the recipient to confirm non-receiptUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.4

When the loss of a whole package cannot be otherwise confirmed, UPS obtains a written statement from the consignee that it was not received, and may ask for a police report. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.4; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPS$100 per package without a declared valueUPS Terms 2026, Section 56

Without a declared value above $100, UPS liability is limited to $100 per domestic package. A declared value is not insurance. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 56; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSOnly the part damaged, at the lesser valueUPS Terms 2026, Section 56.2

UPS pays no more than the lesser of the liability limit, the price paid by the consignee, the actual cost, the replacement cost or the repair cost; for a set, only the part lost or damaged. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 56.2; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSDelivery to the address counts as deliveryUPS Terms 2026, Definitions; Section 22

Delivery includes delivery to the address or to any person present there, and delivery under driver release; UPS may deliver without a signature unless one was required. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Definitions; Section 22; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSTheft after an unsigned delivery: Package ShieldUPS Terms 2026, Section 56.4

A package left without a signature counts as delivered. With UPS Package Shield, when it was bought for the shipment, a theft before the receiver takes possession becomes UPS's liability; fraud by the consignee stays excluded. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 56.4; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSReleased packages are not eligible for lost claimsUPS, File a Claim, FAQ, why can't I submit my claim

Packages the recipient chose to have the driver release are not eligible to be submitted for lost claims. Source: UPS, File a Claim, FAQ, why can't I submit my claim; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSOne open claim per issueUPS, File a Claim, FAQ, current investigation open

A claim cannot be submitted when one is already open regarding the same issue. Source: UPS, File a Claim, FAQ, current investigation open; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSups.com: start a claim within 60 daysUPS, File a Claim, When to file a claim; FAQ, past liability

UPS's claim page says to start a claim within 60 days of the scheduled delivery, and may refuse an online claim as past liability: submitting a claim has to be taken care of within a timely manner of delivery. Source: UPS, File a Claim, When to file a claim; FAQ, past liability; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSUPS acknowledges and numbers each claimUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.2

UPS acknowledges a proper claim within 30 days of receipt and gives it a claim file number. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.2; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSResolution in about 8 to 10 business daysUPS, File a Claim, Under review; Resolution

Unless more investigation is required, a resolution typically comes in 8 to 10 business days. If approved, the shipper may need to provide payment documents; payment follows about 3 days after they are validated. Source: UPS, File a Claim, Under review; Resolution; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

UPSAfter a UPS denial: two years, arbitration or small claimsUPS Terms 2026, Section 55.3; Individual Binding Arbitration of Claims

The terms set no appeal step for a denied claim. A suit must be instituted within two years after the denial of any portion of it; disputes go to individual binding arbitration, except those that qualify for courts of limited jurisdiction such as small claims. Source: 2026 UPS Tariff/Terms and Conditions of Service, United States (effective 17 Apr 2026), Section 55.3; Individual Binding Arbitration of Claims; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSDamage: file right away, within 60 days of mailingUSPS DMM 609, 609.1.4a; usps.com/help/claims, Step 1

Damaged or missing contents: file a claim immediately, and no later than 60 days from the mailing date. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.1.4a; usps.com/help/claims, Step 1; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSLoss: from day 15 to day 60 after mailingUSPS, Domestic claims, Step 1, filing periods table; DMM 609.1.4b

Lost Priority Mail and USPS Ground Advantage: file no sooner than 15 days and no later than 60 days from the mailing date. Priority Mail Express: 7 to 60 days. Source: USPS, File a USPS Claim: Domestic, Step 1, filing periods table; DMM 609.1.4b; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPS$100 included on Priority Mail and Ground AdvantageUSPS DMM 503, 503.4.2

Priority Mail and USPS Ground Advantage, retail and commercial, are insured for up to $100 when the piece bears the required barcodes (an Intelligent Mail package barcode, and an Intelligent Mail matrix barcode or a retail tracking barcode) and was paid at retail or commercial prices. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 503, Extra Services, 503.4.2; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSEvidence of coverage, kept until the claim is resolvedUSPS DMM 609, 609.3.1c

The customer keeps evidence of the service bought until the claim is resolved. Acceptable examples include, for insurance bought online, the online label record: tracking number, postage, insurance fee, declared value, mailing date, origin and destination ZIP Codes, with evidence of mailing. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.3.1c; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSProof of value: receipt, invoice, transaction recordUSPS DMM 609, 609.3.2

Proof of value is the cost or value when mailed: a sales receipt, a paid invoice, a card statement, or a printout of the online transaction naming buyer and seller, price paid, date, the item purchased, and that the transaction is completed. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.3.2; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSKeep the box and everything in itUSPS DMM 609, 609.2.0; usps.com/help/claims, Proof of damage

For damage, the addressee keeps the mailing container, all packaging and all contents, and presents them at a Post Office if USPS asks in writing; otherwise the claim is denied. Undamaged items are kept too. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.2.0; usps.com/help/claims, Proof of damage; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSPhotos of the extent of damage helpUSPS, Domestic claims, Step 2, Proof of damage

Photos that clearly show the extent of damage help the claim. Source: USPS, File a USPS Claim: Domestic, Step 2, Proof of damage; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSShock damage needs a damaged containerUSPS DMM 609, 609.4.3o

No indemnity for damage caused by shock or the transportation environment without evidence of damage to the mailing container. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.4.3o; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSNothing after delivery by USPSUSPS DMM 609, 609.4.3b

No indemnity for loss, damage or missing contents that occurred after delivery by USPS. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.4.3b; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSMailer or addressee may file; the first to file is paid, if approvedUSPS DMM 609, 609.1.3; 609.5.5

The mailer or the addressee may file. If both claim, payment goes to the one who submitted first and whose claim is approved. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.1.3; 609.5.5; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSDecision in 5 to 10 days, payment 7 to 10 business days laterUSPS, Domestic claims, After you file

USPS usually sends a decision within 5 to 10 days; a claim may be approved in full or in part; payment follows in 7 to 10 business days after approval. Source: USPS, File a USPS Claim: Domestic, After you file; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSA lost package is paid with its postageUSPS DMM 609, 609.5.4

When an insured article is lost, the payment includes an additional amount for the postage (not the fee) paid by the sender. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.5.4; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSAppeal within 30 days, then a final appealUSPS DMM 609, 609.6.2 and 609.6.3; usps.com/help/claims

A partly paid or denied claim can be appealed within 30 days of the decision; a second, final appeal within 30 days of the appeal decision. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.6.2 and 609.6.3; usps.com/help/claims; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

USPSBulk claims need written USPS approvalUSPS DMM 609, 609.1.2

Filing in bulk through the Business Customer Gateway needs written approval by USPS Revenue and Field Accounting; criteria include claim history, reimbursement policy and absence of third-party shipping insurance. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.1.2; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

ShopifyUPS labels bought in Shopify: claim through Shopify SupportShopify Help Center, Submitting a claim with the carriers supported by Shopify Support

For UPS labels bought in Shopify in the United States, the claim form is filled in the order page and sent to Shopify Support, with the reason, product description and category, photos of the damaged products, the packaging and the label, and the claim amount. Source: Shopify Help Center, Submitting shipping claims, Submitting a claim with the carriers supported by Shopify Support; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

ShopifyShipsurance: up to $200 included on eligible labelsShopify Help Center, Shipping insurance with Shipsurance; Submit a claim with Shipsurance

Labels bought in Shopify can carry Shipsurance insurance; up to $200 is included at no cost on each eligible label when Shopify Payments is active and the store is on the Grow, Advanced or Plus plan. An insured shipment is claimed on Shipsurance's form in the Shopify admin. Source: Shopify Help Center, Submitting shipping claims, Shipping insurance with Shipsurance; Submit a claim with Shipsurance; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

ShopifyThe automated email carries no referenceShopify Help Center, Shipping claims process for carriers supported by Shopify Support

After submission, an automated email acknowledges the request without a reference ticket ID; a later reply from Shopify Support carries the reference ticket ID, which is added to the order timeline. Source: Shopify Help Center, Submitting shipping claims, Shipping claims process for carriers supported by Shopify Support; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

ShopifyUSPS labels bought in Shopify: claim with USPSShopify Help Center, Submit a claim directly with the shipping carrier

For USPS labels bought in Shopify, the order page gives a link to file directly with the carrier; the claim is not tracked or stored by Shopify. Source: Shopify Help Center, Submitting shipping claims, Submit a claim directly with the shipping carrier; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

RedoRedo files for labels it provided, credits the label balanceRedo Help Center, How to file; What to expect; FAQ

Redo files carrier claims for labels it provided, not for labels bought elsewhere; a damage claim requires an image; for outbound packages an approved amount is credited to the label balance; claims take 3 to 6 weeks. Source: Redo Help Center, Filing a Shipping Claim with Redo, How to file; What to expect; FAQ; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Merchant commitments (4)

What Magic Mind's own pages promise customers. They shape the reply, never the carrier claim.

Magic MindDamaged order: order number and a photoMagic Mind FAQ, My order arrived damaged

If an order arrived damaged, the customer writes to support with the order number and a photo of the damage. Source: Magic Mind, FAQ, My order arrived damaged; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Magic MindNot received: wait 2 business days after the delivery dateMagic Mind FAQ, My package never arrived

If a package never arrived, the customer waits 2 more business days from the delivery date, then writes to support with the order number. Source: Magic Mind, FAQ, My package never arrived; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Magic MindWrong item: order number, description, photoMagic Mind FAQ, I received the wrong item

If the customer received an item they did not order, they write with the order number, what was ordered, what was received, and a photo. Source: Magic Mind, FAQ, I received the wrong item; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Magic MindShipping Protection replaces the packageMagic Mind, Shipping Protection, Product description

Shipping Protection is sold on the store 'For replacing lost, stolen, and damaged packages'. It is a promise to the customer, not a claim against the carrier. Source: Magic Mind, Shipping Protection, Product description; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Contract conditions to confirm (6)

True for some accounts and not others. The page shows them as open questions, not as facts.

Magic MindWho bought each label, on which accountEvery claim

Where a claim is filed depends on who bought the label: Shopify Shipping, Redo, Magic Mind's own carrier account, or another platform. Not visible from outside.

Magic MindDeclared values, insurance, Package ShieldEvery claim

Whether labels carry a declared value, extra insurance, third-party insurance or UPS Package Shield changes the limit and some rules. The cases here read it from each label record.

Magic MindWho receives the indemnitySettlement

Where the money lands depends on the route: UPS pays the shipper by electronic transfer for claims filed with UPS, Redo credits the label balance, and Shopify's page does not say for claims filed through Shopify Support.

Magic MindWhat Shopify Support or Redo report backPartner routes

After filing through a partner: whether it passes on the carrier's claim number, a status, or only the decision. Shopify promises a reference ticket ID; Redo updates the claim's status and asks to be contacted after 3 to 6 weeks.

Magic MindWho runs Shipping ProtectionCustomer resolution

Whether Shipping Protection is run in-house or by a provider, and whether that provider already recovers from the carrier.

USPSBulk insurance pays wholesale costUSPS DMM 609, 609.4.1l and 609.5.1

If USPS shipments use bulk insurance, indemnity is the lesser of actual value and the wholesale cost of the contents to the sender, not the retail price. Source: USPS Domestic Mail Manual 609, Filing Indemnity Claims for Loss or Damage, 609.4.1l and 609.5.1; read Thu 24 Sep 2026.

Internal choices (12)

Choices this workflow makes, labelled as ours. Each can be changed in one place.

Set by usGive notice within 2 business days of the first reportOur choice

Filed directly with UPS, notice goes within 2 business days of the first report without waiting for every photo: a notice needs only the date of shipment, the tracking number and the nature of the damage. Through Shopify Support or Redo, whose forms need the photos, the same two days apply to a complete form.

Set by usAsk for photos while the box is at handOur choice

The photos a carrier may ask for later are asked of the customer at the first reply, while the box is still at hand. They block filing only where the filing form requires them (Shopify Support; Redo for damage).

Set by usInvestigate a delivered package before any claimOur choice

When tracking shows delivered and the customer has nothing: confirm the address, ask where parcels are usually left, and review the delivery details. No claim is filed and no refusal is sent before that.

Set by usClaim only the affected bottles, at the price paidOur choice

The documented value is the affected bottles at the price paid on that shipment (order total after discounts divided by bottles). Bottles the customer calls sticky are not claimed unless documented.

Set by usOne incident, one caseOur choice

Tickets about the same tracking number and incident merge into one case. A complement or an appeal attaches to the open claim; a replacement package has its own tracking number and its own case.

Set by usUncertain submission: verify, never resendOur choice

If a submission's response is lost or unclear, the case waits in 'confirmation to verify' until someone checks the channel for an existing claim. No second submission meanwhile.

Set by usFiled means a carrier referenceOur choice

A case counts as filed only with a claim reference from the carrier, or a partner's written confirmation that it filed with the carrier. An internal ID, an automated acknowledgment or a support ticket number is recorded as what it is.

Set by usApproved is not paidOur choice

A case is settled when the money or credit received is matched against the approved amount, not when a claim is approved.

Set by usA customer's statement is not a recordOur choice

A customer saying the carrier has accepted or paid changes nothing until a document from the claim channel arrives.

Set by usThe customer never waits for the claimOur choice

The customer's replacement or refund is handled on its own track and never waits for the carrier's answer.

Set by usFollow-up dates we setOur choice

Reply to a customer the same business day; chase a missing Shopify reference after 2 business days; ask Redo for a status after 3 weeks; chase a carrier decision after 10 business days; answer a carrier's request within 2 business days.

Set by usHow days are countedOur choice

A deadline 'within N days after' an event is that event's date plus N days, inclusive. Business days skip weekends only; public holidays are not counted in this demo.

Connections to confirm

Nothing here is connected. These are the accesses a real version would need, and what each one decides.

Support tool

Where customer tickets arrive. Not visible from magicmind.com; the workflow only needs to read messages and attachments and to post a reply draft.

Shopify orders

Order, quantities and the price paid after discounts, which set the documented value. Read access only.

Label provider

Shopify Shipping, Redo, an own UPS or USPS account, or another platform. It decides the route of every claim and holds the label record.

Filing access

Shopify Support claim form, Redo carrier claims, UPS claims at ups.com, USPS claims at usps.com. USPS bulk claims need written approval. No claims API appears in UPS's or USPS's public API catalogs (checked Thu 24 Sep 2026); InsureShield, UPS Capital's insurer, has one for its own policies.

Shipping Protection

Run in-house or by a provider, and whether that provider already recovers from the carrier. It changes who claims, not how the customer is served.